Whether to lease or buy company cars is a core procurement decision. It affects cash flow, tax, risk and the workload of whoever manages the fleet afterwards.
There is no universal winner. This guide sets out the main options and the points that usually decide the answer for a UK business.
The main ways to fund a company car
- Contract hire (business leasing): you pay a fixed monthly rental for an agreed term and mileage, then hand the car back. The lessor owns the car.
- Finance lease: similar monthly payments, but the lessee typically takes on more of the end-of-contract value risk.
- Hire purchase or contract purchase: you pay in instalments, and ownership passes to you at the end (sometimes after a final payment).
- Outright purchase: you pay in full from cash or a loan and own the car from day one.
Contract hire is the most common route for company cars because it is predictable and can be bundled with maintenance.
Leasing: the advantages
- Predictable monthly cost. Rentals are fixed, which makes budgeting easier.
- Lower upfront cash. There is typically no large capital outlay.
- Residual value risk sits with the lessor. If used-car prices fall, you are not left holding the loss on a standard contract hire agreement.
- Maintenance can be bundled in. A maintenance or contract management package spreads servicing, tyres and repairs into the monthly price. It is usually an extra cost, but it makes spending steady.
- Easy refresh cycle. Newer cars at set intervals, with modern safety and emissions technology.
Leasing: the trade-offs
- You never own the asset. You build no equity in the vehicle.
- Mileage and condition rules. Excess mileage and damage charges at the end can be costly if the contract isn't actively managed.
- Early termination charges. Ending a lease before the end of its term usually means a significant penalty.
- Contract admin. Several leases with different providers and end dates create a lot of paperwork.
That last point is where managed support helps. At FMS, our leased vehicle management approach means the lease providers, packages and renewal dates are all managed in one place.
Buying: the advantages
- Ownership and flexibility. You can keep a car for as long as it is useful, or sell it when you choose.
- No mileage restrictions. Useful for high-mileage or unpredictable use.
- Potential resale value. Well-kept vehicles retain value.
- Capital allowances. Tax relief is available on the purchase cost (see below).
Buying: the trade-offs
- Capital tied up. Cash or credit used for cars can't be used elsewhere.
- Residual value risk is yours. If the market drops, you carry the loss.
- Running costs are all yours. You fund and organise servicing, repairs, tyres and disposal.
- VAT. As a general rule, you cannot recover the VAT on buying a car. The exception is where it is used exclusively for business and isn't available for private use.
How the tax compares
Tax doesn't decide the answer alone, but it shifts the numbers. Check your own position with your accountant, particularly as several rules change from April 2027.
Leasing
- If a leased car emits more than 50g/km of CO2, 15% of the rental is disallowed when working out taxable profit. If the agreement separately identifies maintenance charges, the restriction applies only to the rental. Electric cars and cars with CO2 of 50g/km or less are not subject to this restriction.
- You can generally reclaim 50% of the VAT on lease rentals for a qualifying car, because the other 50% covers private use. Maintenance charged separately is not subject to the same block.
Buying
- A new, unused zero-emission car qualifies for a 100% first-year allowance. That relief applies to expenditure up to 31 March 2027 for Corporation Tax (5 April 2027 for Income Tax). The Finance Bill 2026-27 doesn't extend it, so from April 2027 electric cars attract writing-down allowances only.
- For other cars, writing-down allowances apply. Cars at 50g/km or below use the main rate, which GOV.UK currently shows as 14% a year and which falls to 12% from April 2027. Cars over 50g/km use the special rate of 6% a year.
Relief is the same in total, but it arrives more slowly under writing-down allowances, which matters for cash flow.
Whatever the funding route
Employees pay company car tax (BIK) based on the car's list price and CO2 band, and employers pay Class 1A National Insurance at 15% on the benefit. Funding choice doesn't change this. From 6 April 2027, employers must report company car benefits through payroll. Our guide to company car tax covers the detail.
A quick decision guide
Leasing usually suits you if:
- you want predictable costs and low upfront spend;
- you replace cars every three to four years;
- you would like to bundle maintenance;
- you want to avoid residual value risk, particularly on electric vehicles where used values are still developing.
Buying usually suits you if:
- you keep vehicles for many years;
- mileage is very high or hard to predict;
- you have the cash and the time to manage the full lifecycle;
- you can use the capital allowances effectively.
Many businesses use a mix, leasing core company cars and buying specialist or long-life vehicles.
What about electric vehicles?
Electric cars have the lowest company car tax rates, and zero-emission cars are exempt from the 15% lease rental restriction. Because battery technology and used values are changing quickly, many businesses prefer to lease EVs. Our fleet electrification page explains how to plan the move.
FAQs
Is leasing always more expensive than buying?
Not necessarily. Leasing spreads the cost and moves the residual value risk to the lessor. Buying can be cheaper over a long hold, but only if you manage maintenance and disposal well.
Can I include maintenance in a lease?
Yes. Most providers offer maintenance or contract management packages, usually at an extra monthly cost. It is worth checking how well the package is being used.
Do I need to manage lease contracts actively?
Yes. Mileage, damage and end-of-contract charges are where lease costs can creep up. Regular reviews avoid surprises.
Can FMS manage leases from several providers?
Yes. We manage the lease providers, maintenance packages, suppliers and drivers in one place, whichever provider you use.
Talk to us before you commit
If you are comparing quotes or reviewing renewals, we are happy to talk it through. Contact FMS or email team@fmsonline.co.uk.
Sources
- GOV.UK, "Claim capital allowances: Business cars": https://www.gov.uk/capital-allowances/business-cars
- GOV.UK, "Capital allowances: extension of first-year allowances for zero-emission cars and chargepoints": https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/first-year-allowances-for-zero-emission-cars-and-electric-vehicle-chargepoints/capital-allowances-extension-of-first-year-allowances-for-zero-emission-cars-and-chargepoints
- ICAEW, "100% first year allowance for electric cars to end in April 2027" (November 2026): https://www.icaew.com/insights/tax-news/2026/nov-2026/100-per-cent-first-year-allowance-for-electric-cars-to-end-in-april-2027
- HMRC, "BIM47725 and BIM47740: restriction of hiring costs" (GOV.UK): https://www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/business-income-manual/bim47725
- Corporation Tax Act 2009, section 56 (legislation.gov.uk): https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2009/4/section/56
- HMRC, "Motoring expenses (VAT Notice 700/64)" (GOV.UK): https://www.gov.uk/guidance/vat-on-motoring-expenses-notice-70064
- HMRC, "Rates and allowances: National Insurance contributions" (GOV.UK): https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/rates-and-allowances-national-insurance-contributions/rates-and-allowances-national-insurance-contributions
- HMRC, "Prepare for mandatory payrolling of benefits in kind" (GOV.UK): https://www.gov.uk/guidance/prepare-for-mandatory-payrolling-of-benefits-in-kind
This article is general information, not tax or financial advice. Please check your own position with your tax adviser.
